The Election Dispute Settlement Committee upheld the results of the Bhutan Chamber of Commerce and Industry’s presidential election after reviewing complaints filed by three candidates. The BCCI officially announced the result on their Facebook page yesterday. The Election Dispute Settlement Committee found insufficient evidence to disqualify the winning candidate or overturn the election results.
The complaints centred on alleged unfair practices, voting procedures and unequal treatment of candidates.
The Election Dispute Settlement Committee reviewed complaints filed by Phub Zam, Phuntsho Wangdi and Tashi Wangyal.
Phub Zam alleged that Dr Trashi Wangyel violated an election notification by hosting a dinner for eligible voters at Hotel Ugyen on October 13, two days before the election.
The committee confirmed that the dinner took place and that eligible voters attended. However, it could not establish that Dr Trashi Wangyel organised the dinner or that it was intended to influence voters.
She also questioned the decision to hold a second round of voting after she and Dr Trashi Wangyel secured 14 votes each in the first round.
She argued that BCCI Election Guidelines provided for a casting vote in the event of a tie.
However, the committee ruled that holding another ballot was consistent with the applicable election framework, which also provides for re-election in the event of a tie.
She further alleged that Dr Trashi Wangyel voted twice because he also headed the Construction Association of Bhutan. The committee found no evidence of double voting.
Meanwhile, Phuntsho Wangdi questioned the change in the sequence of his name on the Electronic Voting Machine.
He said his name was initially listed first in election-related materials but appeared second on the voting machine.
The committee found that the change followed the alphabetical ordering procedure under the Election Commission of Bhutan’s guidelines.
It ruled that the change alone did not establish unfair treatment or an electoral irregularity.
The committee also examined a complaint by Tashi Wangyal against Phub Zam over an alleged coffee meeting with potential voters at Sky Garden on October 13.
The committee confirmed that the meeting took place but found insufficient evidence that it was intended to influence the voters.
The committee concluded that none of the complaints justified disqualifying Dr Trashi Wangyel or invalidating the election results.
However, it pointed out gaps and ambiguities in the existing BCCI election guidelines and recommended reviewing the rules to prevent similar disputes in future elections.
Following the review, the BCCI upheld the election results.

Dr Trashi Wangyel was elected BCCI President with 19 votes against Phub Zam’s 15 in the second round.
Jamtsho and Tenzin Jamtsho were elected as the two Vice Presidents, along with ten Executive Committee members.
BBS contacted all three complainants. Two could not be reached, while Phuntsho Wangdi said the findings did not come as a surprise.
The election was held on October 15 during the BCCI’s 38th Annual General Meeting.
Karma Wangdi
Edited by Sonam Pem


